NextFin News - Only 11% of Europeans now view the United States as a reliable ally, according to a major survey released Wednesday by the European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR). The data, collected across 15 countries including Germany, France, and the UK, marks a sharp decline from 22% in late 2024 and suggests a fundamental breakdown in the trans-Atlantic security compact. As U.S. President Trump enters the second year of his second term, the perception of Washington has shifted from a protective shield to a "necessary partner" or, for 25% of respondents, a direct rival or adversary.
The survey of 19,000 people reveals a continent preparing for a future without American military guarantees. In almost every country polled, a majority of respondents expressed doubt that the U.S. would intervene to defend them in the event of an attack. This skepticism is driving a sudden policy shift toward European military autonomy. Nearly half of those surveyed now support the issuance of common European Union debt to fund defense spending, a mechanism previously blocked by fiscally conservative nations like Germany and the Netherlands. The shift suggests that external pressure from the Trump administration’s "America First" posture is overriding long-standing internal resistance to deeper EU financial integration.
Leonard Schütte, an International Security Fellow at Harvard University, noted that while many Europeans hope for a return to "normalcy" after the current U.S. administration, such expectations may be misplaced. Schütte, whose research focuses on trans-Atlantic security dynamics, argues that the U.S. pivot toward the Indo-Pacific is a structural reality that will persist regardless of which party holds the White House. Even under a Democratic administration, Schütte anticipates a "sober" relationship that lacks the depth of previous decades. His analysis suggests that the current erosion of trust is not merely a reaction to specific policies, such as the recent tensions over Greenland or Middle East strategy, but a recognition of a permanent change in American priorities.
This "new realism," as described by the ECFR authors, has created a rare moment of consensus among European voters. Support for "buying European" military equipment is now a majority position in countries as diverse as Denmark, Portugal, and Sweden. Even supporters of Euroskeptic parties, including France’s Rassemblement National and Italy’s Fratelli d’Italia, now show greater trust in their European neighbors for defense than in the United States. This convergence of opinion across the political spectrum provides European leaders with a unique window to consolidate defense policy, though the window may close if economic concerns or energy prices begin to dominate the public discourse again.
Despite the collapse in trust toward Washington, European resolve regarding Russia remains surprisingly firm. The survey found that 44% of Europeans consider a return to Russian energy imports a "bad idea," compared to only 27% who support it. This suggests that while Europeans feel abandoned by their traditional protector, they are not yet ready to pivot toward Moscow. Instead, the data points toward a "Kevin: Alone at Home" scenario—a reference used by the study’s authors to describe a Europe that, finding itself suddenly solitary, is forced to rig its own defenses using whatever tools are at hand.
The financial implications of this shift are already surfacing in national budgets. Defense spending is rising across the continent, though the survey warns of potential friction ahead. While there is broad support for stronger defense, voters in Italy, Austria, and Germany remain opposed to cutting other public services to pay for it. This tension suggests that the debate over "Eurobonds" for defense will likely become the central economic conflict in Brussels over the next year. European decision-makers are being urged to act quickly while public support for autonomy remains high, as a worsening economic climate could easily fracture this fragile unity.
Explore more exclusive insights at nextfin.ai.
